Events Calendar

By Year By Month By Week Today Search Jump to month
Download as iCal file

30/11/2021 - AGM

Tuesday 30 November 2021, 19:30 - 22:30
by Secretariat
page1image19878992

Annual General Meeting

Down To Earth (Victoria) Co-operative Society Ltd.

ABN 77 380 803 219

AGM rescheduled to 30 November 2021

2021 Notice of Annual General Meeting - Down To Earth (Victoria) Co-operative Society Limited

Please find attached official notice of 2021 Annual General Meeting (AGM) for Down To Earth (Victoria) Co-operative Society Limited.  It includes candidate statements for the directors’ election, and proposed resolutions for the AGM.  Financial reports will soon follow.   

If you are an active member, you will receive an online ballot for the election of directors by 24 November.  You can check your membership status online using https://dte.coop/online/mcm-members-active, though you will need to register with that website if you haven’t yet done so.  If you are not listed as an active member and believe you should be, please contact the cooperative secretary at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..  

If you haven’t received your ballot by 25 November, please contact the returning officer at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..   

We look forward to seeing you at the AGM.  

Kind Regards,

 

Board of Directors 

Down to Earth (Victoria) Co-operative Society Limited

 

Agenda

  1. Welcome

  2. Confirmation of minutes AGM: 29 November 2020 SGM: 9 and 16 August 2021

  3. Financial reports

  4. Election of directors

  5. Special business

  6. Close

page1image30245632 page1image30245824

Financial Reports
Audited financial reports will be emailed to you shortly.

Questions for the auditor regarding the financials may be emailed to: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Election of Directors
There are three (3) positions for Board of Directors.
Re-nominating board member: Kathy Ernst
Directors elected not standing: Coral Larke, Troy Reid. We thank them for their service and wish them well in their future endeavours.
Retained board members: Elisa Brock, Gary Lasky, Susan Helson, Kate Shapiro
Nominations for 2020 election:

page3image30181440page3image2583376

Nominations for the Board

There are three positions on the Board to be filled at this AGM.
The five candidates standing for election have given the statements below in support of their application.

page4image30264704page4image30266816

Kathy Ernst

page2image19786512

  

I have loved attending ConFest for nearly two decades and am privileged to serve as director.

Ensuring the integrity of DTE as a grass-roots organisation where all members can contribute motivates me.
I have promoted transparency and accountability by making information available to all members.

Excessive or hidden spending promotes a sense of entitlement, undermining us as volunteers. At this time of uncertainty and no income, I have tried to reduce expenditure.
The Board should encourage members to be involved. Also, the Board needs to ensure the Co-operative fulfills its legal and ethical obligations. Some have been neglected over many years. I have pushed hard to change processes which undermine or obstruct members’ involvement, tried to clear up outstanding

compliance issues, and improve our processes and accounting systems.
Two years without a ConFest workload allowed us an opportunity to improve these things. It is disappointing and frustrating that my efforts have been obstructed by some Board members. Yet, I would like to continue.
ConFest must remain a participant-created gathering and DTE an idealistic volunteer organisation.
My daughter has been lucky enough to grow up with ConFest. Together let’s ensure future generations can experience the magic of ConFest.

 


Robin MacPherson

page2image19787552

  

I stand as a candidate to bring to the board much needed experience, extensive event awareness as well as an excellent working knowledge of how our systems work and who our members are. I know most of you and you know me, it’s been a 25 year journey.

We need to steady the boat, steady DTE and I can help do this and you can read in more depth how we can do this here - http://abetterdte.com
I believe members want less politics and just want to see a well run board facilitating a participatory co-operative.

Some of my DTE Achievements are
● Fincom - Memcom - Confest Online - New http://dte.coop Website, Bylands Ecology

Plans for Next Term
● Reinvigorate Memcom - Ecology Project - DTE Newsletter - Implement a Secretariat - Launch an Online Event - Revenue Diversification

My focus would be helping the board redefine what it is involved in and what it is not. We should be enabling all our committees and I will continue to work to bring about more transparency, good behaviour and good governance to DTE.

Let's get the board back on track - http://abetterdte.com

 


John Magor

page2image19787344

  

Confest is VERY dear to my heart.

I strongly believe that - ‘it’s my Confest, it’s your Confest, it’s our Confest’.
Confest has, and always will belong to you and me.

Having volunteered in Rangers, Site Operations, as well the Organising Committee, Confest Committee, and Facilitators Forums, and establishing & co-facilitating the Dispute Resolution & Complaints Handling Group (‘DR CHIG’), I have a deep, broad, and balanced

understanding of the dynamics within our organisation.

I highly value community, social justice, honesty, decency, open communication, and transparency, and see potential to further encourage the Board to consider and model these responsibilities between fellow Directors & therefore to all Members of our
cooperative.

If elected, I would value in a Director's role the opportunity to encourage and foster better relationships and cooperation between the Board and DTE Committees.

It has been my privilege to regularly chair DTE meetings, where I encourage all people to be heard and have their input valued. And with the same spirit, I hope to further encourage the inclusion of all voices within our community, and hold in high regard any and all roles I undertake within DTE.


Tania Morsman

page2image19787968

 

This is exciting – to stand as a Director for Down To Earth.

To me the essence of DTE are the Members and Volunteers who make ConFest happen.
We are amazing people who hold space for a wider community to gather in nature to celebrate human connection.

As a current Member and Volunteer I understand how integral it is for Directors to work together with Members and Volunteers. After all peoples, it is these amazing humans who form the foundation of DTE and ConFest.

I understand that the Board bare the responsibility of legal financial obligation however, it is the day to day running that the Members have a great responsibility for. I do not see that the Boards role is to make decisions in its entirety as a father body, but rather, to encourage and foster relationships together that hold equal status of decision with Members.

I see DTE as a mother in a sense. She was conceived through feminine nurturing essence, and the more we go back to this energy the more we will greatly improve the relationships between us all.

I reckon, these days I can give my best self in a situation of unrest, as well in its harmony. I’ve been very fortunate to have had a great learning with DTE in many ways. They include all the beautyfull friendships, the conflicts, the lovers, the working bees, as a volunteer in coordination roles, as a mighty cook and bush bread baker, and an awesome labyrinth creator.

I effin’ love DTE and I would love to be a part of the Board. Communication is one of my skills and well, DTE did pay for me to learn mediation skills! I’ve used those skills lovingly in DTE and I’m great’full.

I would love that you vote for me.

Love
Tania <3 


Lance Nash

page2image19788176

 

ConFest will return but there will be conditions set around that return and it will need to adapt further in the short term. DTE’s challenge is to manage the required changes while ensuring ConFest remains free and egalitarian.

This would be a big ask, under the best of circumstances, let alone when the Co-operative is locked in bitter conflict which is as far from peace and love as I have seen.

There is little creative engagement with members and volunteers although the proposed Gathering at Bylands and the current version of ConFab offer hope.

Where to now? I have a few suggestions:

  •   Engage with the broader membership, volunteers and ConFesters through a regular

  •   Newsletter and coordinated publicity, and seek their input.

  •   Ensure that Board processes are transparent and open to members and Directors are accountable.

  •   Develop the role of Secretary to facilitate outreach to our community.

  •   Investigate alternative income streams from use of DTE’s properties and running events other than ConFest.

  •   Seek advice on how the rules apply, particularly regarding the relationship between the Board and its Committees.

  •   Review the complaints process, report the overall profile of complaints on hand to members and outsource complaints handling. 


page4image30267200page4image30267008

Motion 1: Appoint an Auditor

Motion 2: (special resolution) Change to Rule 44(2)(a) and (b)

Motion 3: (special resolution) Change to Rule 44(4)

Motion 4: (special resolution) Change to Rule 44(5)

Motion 5: (special resolution) Change to Rule 47(8)

Motion 6: (special resolution) Change to Rule 47(16)(d)(iii, iv, v, viii and xi)

 

Special Business for Annual General Meeting 2021

Motion 1: Appoint an Auditor

That DTE appoints Daniel Tai of Ax3 Partners as DTE’s auditor.

Proposed by: Kathy Ernst
Supported by: John Magor, Tania Morsman, Suzie Helson, Don Royal

Explanation:
The Board has appointed Daniel Tai of Ax3 Partners as DTE’s auditor starting with the 2020/2021 Financial Reports for the 2021 AGM. The CNL states that an auditor appointed by the Directors holds office until the next AGM. (CNL section 298). The members should reconfirm this appointment at this AGM.

 

Motion 2: (special resolution) Change to Rule 44(2)(a) and (b)

That the Rules of DTE be modified to make it clear that Director inactivity credits only be lost for Regularly Scheduled meetings, not meetings called with short notice. There will need to be a change to two points in the Rules, 44(2)(a) and 44(2)(b) from the current wording to the proposed wording. (The change is underlined for clarity and should be removed before insertion to the Rules if accepted)

Current wording:
44(2)(a) failure to attend a Board meeting, without agreement by the

Board, 4 (four) credits deducted, and
(b) failure to attend within 30 minutes of the agreed starting time of a Directors meeting without agreement of the board, and for each 45 minutes or part of the meeting absent 1 (one) credit deducted.

Proposed wording:
44(2)(a) failure to attend a regularly scheduled Board meeting, without agreement by the Board, 4 (four) credits deducted, and
(b) failure to attend within 30 minutes of the agreed starting time of a regularly scheduled Directors meeting without agreement of the board, and for each 45 minutes or part of the meeting absent 1 (one) credit deducted.

Proposed by: Graham Fleming
Supported by: Grant Waldram, Dan Smith, Jude Murray, Robin MacPherson

Explanation:
There is currently much controversy between the Board and the Organising Committee (OC) of which some has been caused by the OC not accepting that sufficient notice was not given to all board members for a non-scheduled meeting. This change to the rules would clarify this issue.

 

Motion 3: (special resolution) Change to Rule 44(4)

That the Rules of DTE be modified to clarify the process in which a Directors position becomes 'automatically' vacant should a Director lose the required number of inactivity points, changing Rule 44(4) from the current wording to the proposed wording. (The change is underlined for clarity and should be removed before insertion to the Rules if accepted)

Current wording:
44(4) When any Director reaches zero (0) points in any 12 month period, that Directors position is automatically declared vacant.

Proposed wording:
44(4) When any Director reaches zero (0) points in any 12 month period, that Directors position is to be automatically declared vacant by the Board by way of a majority motion which shall be recorded in the Directors meeting minute book.

Proposed by: Graham Fleming
Supported by: Grant Waldram, Dan Smith, Jude Murray, Robin MacPherson

Explanation:
There has been much aggravated discussion between the Board and the Organising Committee regarding the tally of inactivity credits lost by a couple of Board members. The OC took it upon themselves to declare the Directors positions vacant when there continued to be some doubt within the Board as to the current correct tally of points by these Board members. This has caused much conflict between those involved, spilling out to the general membership. This conflict is not good for DTE and as such the wording of the Rules need to be clarified.

page7image12501760 page7image12502336

Motion 4: (special resolution) Change to Rule 44(5)

That the Rules of DTE be modified to clarify that a Director offering an apology for missing a meeting should be treated as if the Director has applied for a Leave of Absence, changing Rule 44(5) from the current wording to the proposed wording. (The change is underlined for clarity and should be removed before insertion to the Rules if accepted)

Current wording:
44(5) A Director may apply for a leave of absence without loss of inactivity credits. The majority of the remaining board may, within seven days of the request, accept or deny the application but the Board shall not grant a leave of absence for more than three monthly meetings.

Proposed wording:
44(5) A Director may apply for a leave of absence with an apology for the meeting or a formal request for a Leave of Absence without loss of inactivity credits. The majority of the remaining board may, within seven days of the request, accept or deny the application but the Board shall not grant a leave of absence for more than three monthly meetings.

Proposed by: Graham Fleming
Supported by: Grant Waldram, Dan Smith, Jude Murray, Robin MacPherson

Explanation:
There is much dissension among the Board and OC as to the correct way to ask for a leave of absence, thus not losing inactivity credits. Normal meeting conventions recognise that an apology is all that is required for an absent member to be recognised as not attending. This change to the Rules should clarify the intent of the rule.

Motion 5: (special resolution) Change to Rule 47(8)

That the Rules of DTE be modified to clarify that the Board of DTE is the controlling entity of DTE and that the committees of the Board undertake the work as directed by the Board, changing Rule 47(8) from the current wording to the proposed wording. (The change is underlined for clarity and should be removed before insertion to the Rules if accepted)

Current wording:
47(8) The Organising Committee of the Board is responsible for the day to day running of the Society.

Proposed wording:
47(8) The Organising Committee of the Board is responsible for the day to day running of the Society as directed by the Board.

page8image12559168 page8image12559360

Proposed by: Graham Fleming
Supported by: Grant Waldram, Dan Smith, Jude Murray, Robin MacPherson

Explanation:
The Board and the Organising Committee are in constant conflict regarding which entity is in control of DTE. As Australian legislation dictates that the Board and the individual directors are both legally responsible for the actions of DTE, it needs to be clear who is in control. Hopefully this small change will bring some tranquillity back into the coop.

 

Motion 6: (special resolution) Change to Rule 47(16)(d)(iii, iv, v, viii and xi)

That the rules be modified to prevent Organising Committee meetings occurring at short notice or at the end of Board meetings and CC meetings, The section of the rules relating to this is Rule 47(d) 'The Organising Committee' shall be changed from the Current Wording to the Proposed Wording. (Text to be deleted is highlighted with a strikethrough, and text added is underlined. This highlighting is to be removed and text renumbered before insertion into the rules)

Current wording:
47 (16)(d) The Organising Committee

  1. (i)  The Organising Committee's function is to:

    1. run general meetings of the Co-operative;

    2. be the executive arm of the Co-operative relating to all matters not covered by the other standing Committees of the Board;

    3. regularly record, compile, update, and publish to members, all policies developed by the Board, the Committees of the Board, and general meetings of the Co-operative.

  2. (ii)  Every Organising Committee meeting will be conducted in accordance with Rule 33.

  3. (iii)  Organising Committee Meetings may be held at the same time and place as Board meetings and ConFest Committee meetings, without notice.

  4. (iv)  Organising Committee meetings held at other times shall be announced on the DTE Message Bank and the Internet.

  5. (v)  Organising Committee meetings are limited to three hours duration or the unexpired portion of three hours of a Board or ConFest Committee meeting.

  6. (vi)  Organising Committee Meetings shall not be adjourned.

  7. (vii)  The quorum for an Organising Committee Meeting is ten (10) active members.

  8. (viii)  Active members of the Co-operative can qualify as members of the Organising Committee by attending three (3) of the last five (5) Organising Committee Meetings

  1. (ix)  The Organising Committee can use electronic (internet and telephone) and written (mail and circulation of documents) as part of its meeting process and committee members do not need to be physically present.

  2. (x)  The Organising Committee may delegate specific functions to individuals or sub committees.

  3. (xi)  The Organising Committee shall have a monthly minimum allowance of one hundred dollars ($100) cumulative, and additional operating expenses are to be approved by general meeting motion.

  4. (xii)  The Organising Committee will develop and follow financial and reporting procedures as agreed to by the Board and the Co-operative's Auditor.

  5. (xiii)  The Organising Committee shall complete its accounts within 30 days of the end of the financial year.

  6. (xiv)  The Organising Committee will publish a set of the Co-operatives accounts and a report once a quarter on the member's section of the Co-operatives website with hard copies available at the next Board and ConFest Committee meeting.

  7. (xv)  All monies are to be allocated to an individual for a specific task and the individual is entirely responsible to account for the funds advanced.

  8. (xvi)  All matters that may impact on the Board's liability shall be presented to the Board for its consideration.

Proposed wording:
47 (16)(d) The Organising Committee

  1. (i)  The Organising Committee's function is to:

    1. run general meetings of the Co-operative;

    2. be the executive arm of the Co-operative relating to all matters not covered by the other standing Committees of the Board;

    3. regularly record, compile, update, and publish to members, all policies developed by the Board, the Committees of the Board, and general meetings of the Co-operative.

  2. (ii)  Every Organising Committee meeting will be conducted in accordance with Rule 33.

  3. (iii)  Organising Committee Meetings may be held at the same time and place as Board meetings and ConFest Committee meetings, without notice.

  4. (iv)  Organising Committee meetings held monthly and at other times as required giving not less than seven (7) days notice via the OC email list and posted on the internet. shall be announced on the DTE Message Bank and the Internet.page10image12220480 page10image12220672page10image12220864 page10image12221056 page10image12221248

  1. (v)  Organising Committee meetings are limited to three hours duration or the unexpired portion of three hours of a Board or ConFest Committee meeting.

  2. (vi)  Organising Committee Meetings shall not be adjourned.

  3. (vii)  The quorum for an Organising Committee Meeting is ten (10) active members.

  4. (viii)  Active members of the Co-operative can qualify as members of the Organising Committee by attending three (3) of the last five (5) regular monthly Organising Committee Meetings.

  5. (ix)  The Organising Committee can use electronic (internet and telephone) and written (mail and circulation of documents) as part of its meeting process and committee members do not need to be physically present.

  6. (x)  The Organising Committee may delegate specific functions to individuals or sub committees.

  7. (xi)  The Organising Committee shall have a monthly minimum allowance of one hundred dollars ($100) cummulative cumulative, and additional operating expenses are to be approved by general meeting motion.

  8. (xii)  The Organising Committee will develop and follow financial and reporting procedures as agreed to by the Board and the Co-operative's Auditor.

  9. (xiii)  The Organising Committee shall complete its accounts within 30 days of the end of the financial year.

  10. (xiv)  The Organising Committee will publish a set of the Co-operatives accounts and a report once a quarter on the member's section of the Co-operatives website with hard copies available at the next Board and ConFest Committee meeting.

  11. (xv)  All monies are to be allocated to an individual for a specific task and the individual is entirely responsible to account for the funds advanced.

  12. (xvi)  All matters that may impact on the Board's liability shall be presented to the Board for its consideration.

Proposed by: Graham Fleming
Supported by: Dan Smith, Robin MacPherson, Jude Murray

Explanation:
In the last 12 months there has been in excess of 40 meetings, some held at the conclusion of board meetings and Confest Committee meetings and at other times at sometimes very short notice. This has resulted in OC members losing voting rights at future meetings due to the irregular nature of meetings while also forcing OC members to attend Board and CC meetings just in case an OC meeting is called. This change is an attempt to limit the number of OC meetings where meetings are being called for non-urgent matters.

page11image12264256 page11image12264448 page11image12264640 page11image12264832 page11image12265024

Supporting document for motions 2-5:

Explanation from Grant Waldram

In giving formal support (per Special Resolution rule 28(5)) to the four motions for proposed changes, I'd like to present the following thoughts as an "attached document" for everyone who is considering voting on them, and as such would ask that the returning officer please include them with the meeting notice, as I want members to understand precisely WHY I'm giving them my support. Rule changes are important, and I haven’t given this support lightly.

  1. This goes straight to intent. The director points function in two ways. Firstly, much like the activity rule relating to attendance at OC/CC meetings, the intent is to ensure that directors are maintaining an understanding of the issues involved in discharging their office. Secondly, they aim to ensure that a director cannot deliberately impair the functioning of the board by not attending meetings. In a scenario where the rest of the organisation is functioning as intended, the regularly scheduled meetings of the board SHOULD be enough for the board to conduct all of its business - it was designed that way, else there would be more regularly scheduled meetings. There are no adequate provisions for receipted notification of additional board meetings, and hence no reasonable way of proving that non-attendance was malicious, which leaves the gap for suspicion and ambiguity. Indeed, we have seen exactly this scenario play out. Thus there seems to be no basis for attaching a penalty. This change removes that gap.

    As a further observation on this matter of original intent, please note that Rule 44 (5) currently refers specifically to leave of absence being granted for "monthly meetings", suggesting that these are the only meetings from which it was anticipated that a leave of absence would be required. Indeed, it's completely plausible that a malicious cohort could call meetings that it knows a particular director is unable to attend due to other commitments (they may serve on a board of another organisation, may have regular shifts in a job they can't take leave from, etc etc). It follows that it is likely that the regular monthly meetings were the meetings at which the points could be lost. This change clarifies that intent.

  2. This change attaches an unarguable process to the "automatic" removal of directors who have lost all their (in?)activity points. Whilst it may seem to have a weakness that a cabal of friendly directors could simply ignore the zero points status and not vote to remove, that would be a clear and demonstrable act of fraud, and that could, and I expect would, be easily and swiftly prosecuted by members. The consequences for a director proven to be engaging in fraud are ENORMOUS, and that gives the proposed change very significant teeth indeed.

  3. This is simply a way of formally declaring something that should, in a sensible world, need no clarification. An apology is an acknowledgement that the meeting was to be held and that attendance was expected, but is unable to be carried out. Any application for exception from points deduction should be implied, and to impose a separate demand is just petty and trivial.

  4. The proposed change makes no alteration to the stated and intended delegations of powers to the standing committees that currently exist in the rules. What it DOES bring is a reminder that the powers belong to the board in the first instance, and that those powers have been delegated. In extremes, it is wholly within the power of the board to recall those powers for specific purposes - but not permanently. As I've said repeatedly when I served on the board, it has a responsibility to step in and protect the organisation particularly from existential threats, and further a responsibility to protect both the organisation, itself (the board) and by extension board members from legal liabilities. This provision does NOTHING to remove the delegations written into our rules, and doesn't make any provision for the board to permanently recall powers.

These changes are, to my mind, all ones that bring clarity to areas of ambiguity, and as such I am happy to support them.

Grant Waldram

 

Google
Sharepoint
Dte.coop
Dte.org.au
 
Location

Zoom Room
Meeting ID: 236 280 3699
Passcode: 123456
Dial by your location
• +61 3 7018 2005 Australia
• +61 7 3185 3730 Australia
• +61 8 6119 3900 Australia
• +61 8 7150 1149 Australia
• +61 2 8015 6011 Australia
• +64 3 659 0603 New Zealand
• +64 4 886 0026 New Zealand
• +64 9 884 6780 New Zealand
 

MEETING AGENDA
Generally our meetings run to the same agenda
Roles
* Chairperson
* Minute Keeper
* Chat Moderator

Timeline
* Each standing committee has its own agenda
* ConFest Committee
* Organising Committee
* Board